I’ve been biting my tongue for ages by not mentioning that pulse. I assumed you weren’t openly teaching it because it would confuse people and also lead to people prescribing DGSNT inappropriately when they probably should be harmonizing. Thanks for mentioning it and hopefully people find they do more benefit than harm. I understand it potentially more through the angle of JueYin Liver Blood not only becoming cold and deficient, but also contracting from that chronic state. But that still doesn’t fully make sense. Personally I’ve seen it working and being present more in men that have some old liver issues. One patient comes to mind that has a genetic problem of B12 production and needs monthly injections. He has a big hollow left guan and has seen great improvement with DGSNT. Once I tried a XXT to see if I should harmonise him and gee that didn’t go well.